Summary
Overview
This episode examines the 2016 death of Alyssa Romine Olson, a 30-year-old woman found floating naked in a pond at Gilbert, Arizona's Riparian Preserve. Despite suspicious circumstances and police privately acknowledging possible foul play, authorities crafted a narrative suggesting suicide or accident. The investigation heavily focused on her estranged husband Brayden, whose bizarre behavior and statements raised red flags, though he had a solid alibi. The case remains undetermined over a decade later, with Part Two promised to explore additional suspects and Alyssa's connections to controversial religious movements.
The Discovery and Initial Investigation
On June 10, 2016, Alyssa Romine Olson's body was discovered floating naked in a shallow pond at the Riparian Preserve in Gilbert, Arizona. Authorities immediately began crafting a narrative about a depressed woman who had recently separated from her husband, suggesting no foul play. However, the scene revealed troubling details: all of Alyssa's belongings were missing, footprints and shoe treads were found in the mud, and a latex glove was discovered nearby. The medical examiner ruled both cause and manner of death as undetermined, with no water found in Alyssa's lungs.
- Alyssa's body was found floating in extremely shallow water - only 5.5 inches deep at one ankle, less than an inch at the other
- She was found completely naked with no clothing, journal, cell phone, or keys ever recovered
- Footprints, shoe treads, and a latex glove were found at the scene, suggesting she wasn't alone
- The medical examiner ruled cause and manner of death as undetermined, with no water in her lungs
- Mud was found caked on Alyssa's hands, toes, and balls of her feet
- Results from the sexual assault kit were heavily redacted in the case file
" Therefore, because it is unknown how or exactly when the decedent came to be facedown within the water, and because there are no gross anatomic abnormalities potentially causing or related to death, it is my opinion that Alyssa Nicole Olson, a 30-year-old Caucasian female, died as a result of undetermined. "
" Are we supposed to accept that people in Gilbert just keep dying without explanation? "
Who Was Alyssa: Faith and Lifestyle
Alyssa was one of 12 children in the Romine household and underwent a profound spiritual awakening in her late 20s. Her faith became so intense that she relied on God for even minor daily decisions like what to wear or eat. She met her husband Brayden at the International House of Prayer in 2012, and they quickly married that winter. The couple lived a nomadic lifestyle for three years, traveling the country to preach and minister, sharing everything including social media accounts and a single cell phone.
- Alyssa underwent a spiritual awakening in her late 20s, with her faith becoming the guiding force in nearly every aspect of her life
- She was so devout she relied on God to tell her what clothes to wear and what to eat, ridding herself of most personal belongings
- Alyssa met Brayden at the International House of Prayer in mid-2012 and married him within months
- The couple lived nomadically for three years, couch surfing and preaching, with Alyssa's parents helping them financially
- They were attached at the hip, sharing social media accounts and a cell phone which they rarely answered
" Jesus wanted her to marry Brayden "
📚 9 more sections below
Sign up to unlock the complete summary with all insights, key points, and quotes
Get this summary + all future Crime Junkie episodes in your inbox
100% Free • Unsubscribe Anytime
Sign up now and we'll send you the complete summary of this episode, plus get notified when new Crime Junkie episodes are released—delivered straight to your inbox within minutes.