Summary
Overview
In this updated investigation of the 1945 Sodder children case, Miranda Weeks—great-great-granddaughter of one of the surviving Sodder children—presents newly uncovered case records that cast serious doubt on the official conclusion. Five children vanished during a Christmas Eve house fire in West Virginia, but no remains were ever found. The episode examines suspicious circumstances including severed phone lines, missing equipment, questionable local officials with ties to George Sodder's former boss, and expert testimony suggesting the children couldn't have been consumed by the fire.
The Night of the Fire
On Christmas Eve 1945, George and Jenny Sodder's home in Fayetteville, West Virginia caught fire around 1 a.m. While six family members escaped, five children—Maurice, Martha, Louis, Jenny, and Betty—never made it out. Everything that could go wrong did: the ladder was mysteriously missing, the trucks wouldn't start, the phone line was cut, and the fire department took seven hours to arrive despite being called multiple times. The house burned to ash in just 30-45 minutes.
- Jenny Sodder received a wrong number call around 12:30 a.m., then heard a thud on the roof before smelling smoke around 1 a.m.
- The office across from the stairs to the children's bedrooms was already engulfed in flames, trapping five kids upstairs
- George's ladder that was always on the side of the house had mysteriously disappeared
- Both family trucks had flooded engines and wouldn't start despite being functional earlier
- The fire department took seven hours to arrive, despite multiple calls for help
- The entire house burned to ash within 30-45 minutes according to the family
" There are kids trapped in there. "
The Missing Remains Mystery
Despite an intensive search of the wreckage, investigators found absolutely no human remains—no bones, no teeth, nothing from five children. This became the central mystery that Jenny Sodder couldn't accept. Items like coins, a kitchen stove, a dictionary, and pieces of Jenny's coat survived the fire, yet somehow five bodies completely disappeared. Fire experts then and now agree this is physically impossible for a house fire.
- Zero human remains were recovered during the initial search—not a single bone or tooth from five children
- Flammable items like parts of a dictionary and Jenny's coat survived the fire, yet bones supposedly didn't
- Jenny conducted her own experiments at home in 1946 using animal bones and could never get them to turn to ash
- A retired firefighter wrote that even in extremely hot fires, bodies remain recognizable
- Modern fire investigator Dale Rison confirmed a 1945 house fire couldn't burn hot enough to destroy remains in 30-45 minutes
" You cannot declare that someone died in a fire and not have human remains. "
📚 6 more sections below
Sign up to unlock the complete summary with all insights, key points, and quotes
Get this summary + all future Crime Junkie episodes in your inbox
100% Free • Unsubscribe Anytime
Sign up now and we'll send you the complete summary of this episode, plus get notified when new Crime Junkie episodes are released—delivered straight to your inbox within minutes.