Summary
Overview
Justin Gold transformed a simple idea about making better peanut butter into Justin's Nut Butters, a category-defining brand worth hundreds of millions of dollars. Starting with just a food processor in his Boulder apartment in 2002, Justin spent years experimenting with flavors, bootstrapping through farmer's markets, and eventually creating the game-changing squeeze pack format that propelled the brand to national success. After selling to Hormel for $280 million in 2016, Justin was later let go but has now returned to help revive the brand under new ownership.
The Origin Story: From Law School to Peanut Butter
Justin Gold grew up in western Pennsylvania and initially studied to become a lawyer, but instead became a vegetarian hippie who moved west to find his people. Landing in Boulder, Colorado in 2001, he waited tables and worked at REI while noticing something odd: grocery stores had tons of jam varieties but limited peanut butter options. This observation, combined with his love of peanut butter and banana sandwiches, sparked an idea that would consume the next two decades of his life.
- Justin studied to become a lawyer but moved to California and then Boulder, Colorado instead, working as a waiter to make ends meet
- He noticed grocery stores had extensive jam selections but very limited peanut butter options, mostly just smooth or crunchy
- Justin started mixing peanut butter with jelly and honey at home, realizing he could create better flavored varieties
- He began experimenting with a food processor, buying dry roasted peanuts and almonds from the co-op to make his own nut butters
" I really felt like I was a hippie. And so the goal at that point was to move as far away as I could. And I went to the Bay Area and I lived in Point Reyes and I lived there for about a year. And then I met like, you know, some real like living up the land hippies. And I realized I'm actually quite square and maybe I'm not a hippie, but you know, what am I? Where are my people? Where do I belong. "
" I take the lid off the shoebox and I'm like, I want to make peanut butter. "
The Chemistry Experiments: Solving the Texture Problem
Justin's early experiments weren't just about mixing flavors—they were about solving complex chemistry problems. He discovered that adding honey or other wet ingredients to peanut butter created texture issues after a few days because oil and water don't mix. This led to months of experimentation with different ingredients, percentages, and temperatures, keeping detailed journals of every formulation. He experimented with banana chips, freeze-dried fruits, powdered ingredients, and different types of peanuts, eventually creating 30-40 numbered jars stored at different temperatures.
- Adding honey to peanut butter initially tasted great, but after a few days the texture became mealy due to water activity in the oil
- Justin experimented with different forms of banana: chips, freeze-dried, dried, and syrups, testing various percentages
- He kept detailed journals numbering each jar and tracking ingredient percentages, storing some in cupboards and some in refrigerators to understand temperature impacts
- Even a simple three-ingredient product like honey peanut butter required testing multiple peanut varieties, roast levels, and skin-on versus skinless options
📚 12 more sections below
Sign up to unlock the complete summary with all insights, key points, and quotes
Get this summary + all future How I Built This with Guy Raz episodes in your inbox
100% Free • Unsubscribe Anytime
Sign up now and we'll send you the complete summary of this episode, plus get notified when new How I Built This with Guy Raz episodes are released—delivered straight to your inbox within minutes.