Page 94: The Private Eye Podcast
Page 94: The Private Eye Podcast

161: Unwise Councils

December 02, 2025 • 44m

Summary

⏱️ 9 min read

Overview

The Page 94 podcast discusses three major topics: Reform UK's chaotic experience running local councils after electoral success, the Democratic Party's lack of clear leadership in the US alongside Your Party's decision not to elect a leader in the UK, and the ongoing sale of The Telegraph newspaper to Lord Rothermere's Daily Mail group. The hosts examine how these leaderless parties and institutions are managing (or failing to manage) their responsibilities and what this means for politics and media.

Reform UK's Local Council Struggles

Reform UK stormed into local government with promises to cut hundreds of millions in expenditure, but reality has proven far different from rhetoric. The party now controls 10 local authorities but has lost approximately 40 councillors through resignations, suspensions, and sackings. Kent, their flagship borough under leader Lyndon Kemcaran, exemplifies the problems: claimed savings are actually accounting tricks, and Reform councillors are discovering that councils can't control immigration policy or stop asylum hotels—the very issues they campaigned on.

  • Reform claims to have cut £331 million in expenditure across their 10 controlled councils, but this is mostly rhetoric over reality
  • Kent's claimed savings involve cutting councillors' allowances by 5% but redirecting that money into a community fund, so it's not actually a saving
  • Reform councillors came in promising to end DEI spending and cut special educational needs funding, but local authorities have legal duties to provide certain services
  • Kent started with 57 Reform councillors but now has only 48, with nine having left through various means
  • Reform councillors discovered they have no power over immigration or asylum hotels, despite these being central to their campaigns
" I think the answer is rhetoric over reality. "
" These are elected members, public monies, public sector money, that's being wasted. These are people who are held to account except they behave like this. "

The Leadership Cult and Infighting

Reform UK's internal culture mirrors Nigel Farage's leadership style, creating a cult of personality at the local level. Kent's Lyndon Kemcaran exemplifies this authoritarian approach, sacking councillors who challenge her authority. The party's high turnover rate mirrors historical problems in UKIP, where Farage's dominance meant other politicians struggled to establish themselves. Meanwhile, the BBC has been accused of targeting Reform by disproportionately reporting on their councillor departures, though this scrutiny reflects Reform's position as potential future government.

  • Lyndon Kemcaran in Kent operates with Jackie Weaver-style authority, booting out councillors who don't submit to her leadership
  • The majority of Kent's nine departed councillors were sacked, with others suspended or leaving due to disagreement with the leadership cult
  • Reform's councillor turnover rate far exceeds other parties, similar to UKIP's historical problems with MEPs
  • Reform are being scrutinized more because they're auditioning to be the next government, topping polls with Farage as potential PM
" He's operating a situation where there is a real cult of leadership there, right? So the Kent leader is a copycat example of that. She has this sort of authority. "

📚 6 more sections below

Sign up to unlock the complete summary with all insights, key points, and quotes